Barclay J. Smith |
Barclay Jeremiah Smith was born June 11, 1834 in Buckmanville, Upper Makefield Township to Ralph Smith and his wife Miranda Walton. These Smiths were descended from William Smith, who emigrated from Yorkshire, England in 1684 and settled in Bucks County and was the progenitor of a proud and large local family. Barclay was a cousin to noted figures local historian Josiah B. Smith and Dr. Lettie A. Smith.
Buckmanville Store Arnold Bros. View |
As a child, Barclay excelled in mathematics and was noted as being a good left-handed pitcher in school games. When he was 23 he bought property in Buckmanville and started a mercantile business. On July 14, 1862, the post office was established, and Barclay was the first postmaster. Barclay speculated land starting in 1857 and at one time or another owned every one of the small lots that compromise the village. Smith's influence was sorely missed when he left for Newtown, and the village's growth came to a sudden halt.
|
From his beginnings at his mercantile store and real estate conveyancing, he would rise to become one of Newtown's most industrious and well-known citizens. Let's start with the first half of his obituary, as it gives insight into how heavily involved with Newtown business affairs Barclay was.
Thirty years ago Barclay J. Smith was a leading business man of Newtown and one of the best-known men in Bucks County. After having been successfully engaged in the mercantile business at Buckmanville for six or eight years, he moved to Newtown, and in the spring of 1864 was instrumental in organizing the First National Bank of Newtown, which was chartered March 4th of that year, and of which he was the first cashier. The meeting for the organization of the bank was held at the Temperance House, and it was opened in the room now used as the express office in the Tomlinson Building on State street and Washington avenue. Barclay only held the position of cashier for about a year, and the withdrew and engaged in the real estate business with Owen W. Worstall, under the firm name of B.J. Smith & Co. For a number of years this firm did a very extensive business, selling many of the properties in middle and lower Bucks county, some of them several times over. Worstall later withdrew from the firm, and Barclay eventually sold out to George K. Ridgeway.
While still in the real estate business, Barclay J. Smith, ever active in business affairs, organized the Newtown Banking Company, of which he was president during the whole of its existence. He built the present Wynkoop Building, in which the Banking Company was established. The Newtown Fire Insurance Company also owed its existence to him. In the building of the Newtown Railroad he was very active.
September 15, 1870 Newtown Enterprise
|
September 23, 1871 Newtown Enterprise |
January 3, 1874 Newtown Enterprise |
March 30, 1872 Newtown Enterprise |
Oct 27, 1877 Newtown Enterprise |
By 1878, things appeared to be going very well for Barclay J. Smith. The railroad opening was a huge event in Newtown, Barclay had shoveled the first spade of dirt in 1872 and was involved throughout the process, perhaps too involved.
The railroad took six years to complete and wasn't without its share of problems. A financial panic in 1873 caused work to be stopped for lack of funds. The company was reorganized after the mortgage on the road was foreclosed, with Barclay J. Smith as treasurer. The bondholders bought into the road and turned their bonds into stock. Eventually, thanks in large part to help from the Newtown Banking Company, the road was opened on February 2, 1878. Newtown was now connected to Philadelphia, which would help the community grow and prosper in the decades to come.
At this time, the Newtown Fire Insurance Company had some losses after a fire in Philadelphia amounting to a few thousand dollars. Barclay was stretched too thin and couldn't borrow any more money, the bubble burst.
The immense costs incurred with the railroad were about to catch up with him, and the others who trusted him. With his hands in so many baskets, businesses were bound to get mingled together. Barclay's business practices got him in over his head and shortly it would all crumble. The local newspapers covered the situation relentlessly, particularly The Newtown Enterprise, which on May 11, 1878 reported:
The Recent Failure - The failure of Barclay J. Smith of this place, was announced on Thursday the 2nd, and the last paper was printed on Friday morning, giving us only time and room to announce the fact in an article prepared mainly by him. A week has intervened, and the subject has been the principal talk of the town and vicinity ever since; and as is natural on such occasions, there have been many exaggerations and misrepresentations.Mr. Smith founded the Newtown Banking Company and the Newtown Fire Insurance Company. He was the principal stockholder of both these concerns, and managed them both, almost exclusively. What the Directors of either institution knew of the business was obtained from him. He also originated the idea of building the Newtown Railroad. He conceived the plan of an association of men joining together, purchasing a charter, organizing a company and issuing bonds, on which bonds the road was to be built. A loss of confidence in all such enterprises, when this organization was just getting under way, ruined its prospects. A number of persons had joined with him in this project, and it was persisted in after all home of the completion of the road under the arrangement should have been given up, entailing very serious loss on many, as well as himself; losses from which some will not be able to recover. The Railroad, the Bank and the Insurance Company were united together by a financial chain. The greater part of the money invested in the Railroad was lost when it was sold, and when Mr. Bush agreed to complete it, nearly all the old indebtedness was wiped out, and he received the new bonds issued under the first mortgage.But the Bank was apparently on a firm foundation. A list of it's stockholders was published on June 18th, 1877, in connection with the settlement of the condition of the Bank at that time. (A list of stockholders follows, with Barclay J. Smith owning 100 shares, and Newtown Insurance Co owning 125 shares. The next highest shareholder held 75 shares and the majority held 10 or less.)This was accompanied by a circular calling attention to the soundness of the Bank, stating that interest would be paid on deposits, and that the stockholders were liable for deposits, principal and interest. There may have been a few changes in the names of the stockholders since that date. The lowest the stock ever sold at public sale was $90, and previous to that it has sold at par. As to the present state of the Bank we know nothing. The Directors met on Friday of Last week. Dr. Benj. Smith, the Cashier, was absent on a visit to his son Edward in Minnesota, and intended when he left to remain about three weeks. Barclay J. Smith was left in charge of the Bank and books, the latter to be put in shape for examination previous to another meeting to be held on Wednesday, the 8th.Barclay J. Smith also owned the grocery and provision store kept in the basement of the bank building, known as the "Rosewood" store, with Lukens Wood as manager. Lukens had no direct interest in the store but was hired to conduct it. This was kept open, and some of the creditors obtained goods. It was intended that the store should pay its debts, independent of any other connection.It is impossible to calculate either the direct or ultimate losses that have and may result from this failure. The stock of the Bank was $100 per share, and it is easy to calculate how much each stockholder will lose directly, but how much they will be involved in paying depositors is not known. This much for the Bank. But apart from this, we learn that the heads of two of the largest and most prominent business firms of the place are involved on account of endorsing paper for Mr. Smith - These gentlemen are among our most enterprising citizens, foremost in any improvement of project for the benefit of the town, conduct business employing a large number of men, and have always enjoyed the confidence and respect of their fellow citizens. We are assured that both these firms (and we may as well name them, Hillborn & Buckman and Hillborn & Worstall,) are sound, and able to meet all liabilities.On Wednesday the Directors of the Bank met and had a consultation with the President, who explained to them the situation of affairs. He acknowledged that he had taken large sums out of the bank and put them in the railroad without the knowledge of the Directors. They adjourned, appointing Geo. A. Jenks, one of their body, to take charge of the books and property of the Bank.Thus far we have endeavored to give the situation of things as we see it, honestly and fairly. There is much talk and rumor. There appears to be a general surprise manifested among stockholders, depositors and others, that the Directors, on ascertaining the condition of affairs, did not take possession of the Bank, the books and papers, and put them in the hands of a proper disinterested person to hold and investigate. It is said the Insurance Company is still doing business. Some time ago the President, Alfred Blaker, resigned, and Cyrus Hillborn was put in his place. Samuel J. Bunting and Oliver H. Holcomb, Directors, also resigned, and we have not heard of their places being filled. The business of the Company is all transacted in Philadelphia.Having published this much it seems proper to give what we suppose was the motive of Mr. Smith in appropriating these funds. A large sum of money had already been invested in the Railroad. To keep the concern alive, to retain possession of it, until arrangements could be made to have it completed, was his constant effort, and to the end he devoted much time, attention and money. He thought if he could regain control of it, it would eventually be completed, become renumberative, and then all the money advanced would be returned or secured. The result was different, and the road passed beyond his control, was lost, and the greater part of the investment sunk. He took the risk and failed. Had he been successful, he would have been praised as a shrewd financier. As he failed, he is denounced, and more severely by those who lose nothing.A meeting of the stockholders is called at the rooms of the Bank on Saturday, May 18th at 2 o'clock PM.Barclay J. Smith furnishes the following statement.The liabilities of the Newtown Banking Company have been ascertained to be as follows: $17,148.54 due on book account to 70 depositors; $23,494.62 due on certificates of deposit, upon which not more than an average of one month's interest is due; $32,481.41 due to banks and bankers, $16,792.00 of which is secured by bonds and stocks; $6,565 due to other parties not bankers. The assets of the bank would be ample under favorable circumstances to meet all these obligations, but at present it is difficult to compute the exact value of some securities held, and a deficiency of $12,000 to $18,000 may exist. Every effort will be made by the board to hasten settlements, and if the creditors will accept the securities and notes held, the whole business could be closed up in a few months; if the whole amount has to be paid in cash, it will take a much longer time to arrive at this result. On examination it is found that most of the notes which cannot now be collected were made in 1874 and 1875, being those of the President of the Bank and other parties engaged in building the railroad, some of which are still good and will have to be met. Nothing was loaned to the Railroad Company direct, but the managers and parties engaged in the work, on individual names, and on collaterals now worthless.
Barclay J. Smith had gotten himself into major financial trouble, and the trusting people of Newtown were the ones who would pay the price.
The Germantown Telegraph reported The failure of the Newtown Banking Company, which will probably close the existence of the Newtown Insurance Company, turns out to be more unfavorable for Barclay J. Smith and the stockholders than was expected. It was as usual the result of the one man power - the Board of Directors being merely so many ciphers.
The time devoted to making a statement of my individual affairs for your examination will not enable me to enter into details, but I ask your patience for a few moments while I give a few facts which led to the unfortunate close of my business career at this place, because I think it is due you and me and those most nearly connected with me, to have set out the cause as well as the result of my sad experience.
Barclay argued With all my embarrassments I never had a doubt of the ability of the bank to meet its engagements, because I believed it secure, to a great extent, although I have advised but one person for a long time to put money in the bank stock or certificate.
Open Letter to B. J. Smith |
The "open letter" of Satterthwaite, Ellis and Rogers, sent to B. J. Smith at Helena, Montana was duly received there, and news of its reception has been returned here. He declines to come on at this time, on account of business complications.
It is further reported that they tried to publish this "open letter" in two of Helena's newspapers but were rejected. It seems that Barclay had secured the sympathies of the press, people and officials of Helena. Barclay's response to the letter was that he declined to come home at that time due to business complications.
March 29, 1879 Newtown Enterprise
|
Shortly after this in June 1879, the papers for bringing Smith back were prepared in Doylestown and a requisition was signed between Governors in Harrisburg. Joseph Rue was once again dispatched for Montana with the expectation that Smith would come home this time.
A dispatch from Bismarck, Dakota, says that detective Joseph Rue, of this city, has reached that place with Barclay J. Smith, ex-Treasurer of the Philadelphia, Newtown and New York Railroad Company, ex-president of the Newtown Banking Company. amd ex-president of the Newtown Fire Insurance Company. Smith was arrested at Helena, Montana, where he had been living in apparent poverty with his family for about a year. He is being brought on to Newtown, Bucks county, to answer to those whose money he is accused of having embezzled. His parting from his family in Montana is said to have been very affecting. When arrested he was preparing to start on an overland trip to Puget Sound. July 10, 1879 Philadelphia Times
When the congregation in Friends Meeting was sitting in silence in the forenoon of Sunday last, who should walk into the house and take his accustomed seat but Barclay J. Smith. He came up on the train, which was somewhat behind time, and came direct from the station to the meeting. When the meeting broke up there was a regular hand-shaking. He looks very well. August 9, 1879 Newtown Enterprise
June 16, 1892 San Francisco Call |
Smith's Cash Store Business Card |
Jan 17, 1897 San Francisco Call |
It is a proud monument to its owner and builder and an everlasting ornament in San Francisco. Smith's Cash Store is a name familiar in almost every household, not alone in San Francisco but throughout California. The growth of this establishment has been phenomenal, and it occupies to-day a leading place among the commercial houses of this coast.
Barclay had once again risen to the heights he dreamed about. From his humble beginnings at the Buckmanville Store, to a six story megastore in San Francisco, Barclay never gave up and found success more times than he lost it.
February 2, 1900 San Francisco Call Bulletin |
June 30, 1900 San Francisco Call Bulletin |
December 15, 1903 San Francisco Chronicle |
The Business Career of the deceased in Bucks County ended with the collapse of the Newtown Banking Company and the Newtown Fire Insurance Company in the spring of 1878, soon after the opening of the Newtown Railroad for travel. Soon afterward he went West, first to Helena, Montana, where he kept an eating house, and later to San Francisco, Cal. and embarked in the mercantile business, the same in the course of time growing to large proportions. In that city by the Pacific the remaining years of his life were spent, his business duties being interspersed with religious work.
Barclay J. Smith was a son of the late Ralph Smith and was born in Upper Makefield township. He was possibly 75 years of age. His wife, who survives, was Lydia A. Wood, of Montgomery county. There are two children - Harper A. Smith, who was engaged in business with his father, and a daughter, Laura M. Greer.
The remains will be brought East and interred with his kindred in the Friends' graveyard at Wrightstown. Notice of the funeral to be held at the meetinghouse at that place appears elsewhere.
After his death, newspapers continued to write about the man and the differing opinions locals had about him. A letter called "The Other Side", penned by "S." shows how some felt towards the deceased.
The "marvelous business rise" of the late deceased, from five dollars to a great building and the employment of one hundred and fifty hands, would strike the reader as being more meritorious and indicate more genuine business ability if it had enabled him to make some restitution to the numbers of women he had made poor, some of them destitute, and children who were deprived of their rightful inheritance because of the losses their parents sustained in the broken bank, the fire insurance, and the other ventures of his which they were over-persuaded into and which proved to be total failures. January 2, 1904 Newtown Enterprise
There were severe reserves occasioned by the collapse of the Newtown Banking Company, and the aged, the widow and the orphan suffered, and the effects are felt yet. No one sympathizes more with these than does the writer of this. That the losses were small compared with those occasioned by a recently wrecked back of this county does not enter into the question but this does: that the money lost in our local institution in 1878 did not go to individual benefit, but mainly for the building of the Newtown Railroad, or to replenish losses of corporations subsidiary to that. Barclay J. Smith was no sporting character reveling in the money wrong from the widow and orphan. Those who visited his home in Newtown saw him living in a plain house in a plain way. He made grievous mistakes in his optimism, and the money he encouraged his friends to put in his undertakings went to the bad, but if it does his financial victims no good, that the process of his borrowing went elsewhere than to his comfort and high living is a factor in his favor.
Ambitious guy!
ReplyDeleteGreat post, Rick! Hellova lot of research.